What Are Aged Insurance Leads?
Aged insurance leads are prospective client contacts who previously showed interest in insurance products but have not been contacted recently. Typically, aged leads are 30, 60, or even 90+ days old, distinguishing them from fresh or exclusive leads, which are immediately delivered to agents upon inquiry.
Differences Between Aged and Fresh Leads:
- Aged Leads: Lower cost, may have already been contacted (often multiple times), but are available in high volume and with flexible filtering
- Fresh/Exclusive Leads: Higher cost, less competition, more immediate interest, but often sold in limited quantities
Pros of Aged Leads:
- Significantly more affordable per lead
- Access to larger volumes and specific filters (location, product, demographics)
- Opportunities often overlooked by agents focused on fresh-only options
Cons of Aged Leads:
- Lower initial response rates
- Higher potential for outdated contact info
- Requires a strategic, persistent follow-up approach
Key takeaway: The right lead is not necessarily the newest lead—the best ROI aged insurance leads offer comes from how you engage and follow up.
Why Consider Buying Aged Insurance Leads?
Cost Comparison: Aged vs. Exclusive/Fresh Leads
Fresh, exclusive insurance leads often cost $20 to $50+ each. In contrast, aged leads can cost $0.25 to $3.00 per lead. That means acquiring 10–100x the volume for the same budget.
Table: Example Cost Comparison
| Lead Type | Cost Per Lead | Leads Purchased for $500 |
| Exclusive/Fresh | $25 | 20 |
| Aged (30-90 days) | $1 | 500 |
Volume and Segmentation
Aged leads providers often allow segmentation by:
- Zip code
- Product type
- Lead age
- Consumer intent
This targeting improves campaign efficiency and ROI.
Overlooked Profit Opportunities
Aged leads can be hidden gems—prospects who needed more time or didn’t get proper follow-up. Strategic outreach helps capture these opportunities others missed.
Related Reading:
- Best Practices for Contacting and Converting Insurance Leads
- How Much Do Aged Leads Cost? A 2025 Price Breakdown
Analyzing the ROI Aged Insurance Leads Provide
ROI Formula
ROI = (Revenue from New Policies – Total Lead Cost) / Total Lead Cost
With aged leads, the upfront cost is lower, but conversions require volume and follow-up.
Example ROI Calculation
- Spend: 500 leads at $1 = $500
- Close Rate: 2% = 10 new clients
- Commission per Sale: $400
- Gross Commission: $4,000
- ROI: ($4,000 – $500) / $500 = 700%
Industry Close Rates
- Aged Leads: 1–3%
- Exclusive Leads: 15–25%
With volume and efficiency, aged leads often outperform on a cost-per-sale basis.
Factors Impacting ROI
- Product line (auto vs. life)
- Speed of contact
- Personalization and script quality
- CRM and follow-up tracking
Strategies to Maximize ROI from Aged Leads
Multi-Touch Follow-Up
- Calls: Vary times—morning, lunch, evening
- Texts: Use to prompt replies or confirm appointments
- Emails: Send helpful, low-pressure updates
Persistence and Cadence
Plan 7–10 touches over multiple channels. Success comes from process, not pressure.
Lead Nurturing Wins
Avoid hard closes. Educate, provide context, and invite questions.
CRM and Tracking
Use automation to:
- Schedule follow-ups
- Score lead engagement
- Optimize touchpoints
Agent Success Story:
“I closed 12 policies from 1,000 aged leads in two weeks using an SMS/email combo and daily calls. That’s $5,000+ on a $900 spend.” — Independent Agent, TX
Related Reading:
- Best Time of Day to Call Aged Leads
- Sales Scripts That Convert Aged Internet Leads
- How to Work Aged Leads: Call Scripts & Timing
Common Pitfalls to Avoid
- Expecting fast results: Success with aged leads takes systems and stamina
- Ignoring compliance: Always scrub DNC lists and respect opt-outs
- Low-quality vendors: Choose suppliers with transparency, filtering, and opt-in data
Final Verdict: Are Aged Insurance Leads Worth It?
Quick Recap
Pros:
- Low cost per lead
- Scalable, filtered data
- Strong ROI with proper follow-up
Cons:
- Lower response rates
- Requires more effort and persistence
Are You Ready?
Ask yourself:
- Do I have systems to manage large lead volume?
- Can I segment by product or region?
- Am I ready to follow up 7–10x if needed?
- Do I work with compliant, vetted lead sources?
If yes, the ROI aged insurance leads deliver could become your agency’s most powerful sales lever.
Related Reading:
- What Are Aged Leads and Who Should Buy Them?
- 5 Reasons Smart Agents Are Switching to Aged Leads in 2025
Related Reading:
